Not Shubman Gill, Former Selector Backs KL Rahul to Bat at Virat Kohli’s Position

In a surprising twist amid growing speculation over Team India’s batting order post-Virat Kohli’s break from cricket, a former national selector has stirred debate by advocating for KL Rahul—not Shubman Gill—to take over the No. 3 position in the Indian lineup.

topbabyworlds.com

With Kohli on a temporary hiatus, fans and pundits have been debating who among India’s current crop of batters should step into one of the most crucial spots in the order. While many have backed Shubman Gill, who has experience opening and recently played at No. 3, former selector Saba Karim believes KL Rahul is better suited for the job.

topbabyworlds.com

KL Rahul the “Ideal Fit”

Speaking in a recent interview, Karim stated, “Gill is a promising talent, no doubt. But KL Rahul brings experience, composure, and versatility to the table. He’s handled pressure situations, especially in ODIs and Tests, and has the temperament needed for No. 3.”

topbabyworlds.com

Karim, who served on India’s selection panel until 2020, pointed to Rahul’s recent form in white-ball cricket and his ability to anchor the innings while rotating strike—a role that Virat Kohli has famously mastered over the years.

topbabyworlds.com

Why Not Shubman Gill?

Despite his prolific run in 2023 and early 2024, Gill’s form has seen ups and downs, especially in challenging overseas conditions. Critics argue he’s still growing into the kind of mature batter needed to stabilize an innings after an early wicket.

topbabyworlds.com

“Gill has all the tools, but No. 3 is a pressure cooker. If we lose a wicket in the first few overs, you need someone with experience and resilience. That’s Rahul,” Karim added.

topbabyworlds.com

A Growing Dilemma for Team India

India’s middle-order conundrum has intensified with Kohli’s absence and the team’s focus shifting to grooming a long-term replacement. Rahul, who has batted everywhere from opener to No. 5, has reinvented himself as a reliable batter in crunch matches—especially in ICC tournaments.

topbabyworlds.com

However, supporters of Gill argue that he represents the future and should be backed with a consistent role. The 24-year-old has already been earmarked as a potential leader and needs clarity in batting position to build confidence.

topbabyworlds.com

What Lies Ahead?

As India prepares for upcoming Test tours and the ICC Champions Trophy in 2025, selectors and the coaching staff will be under pressure to strike a balance between experience and youth.

topbabyworlds.com

With no official word yet from the BCCI on the long-term No. 3 plan, the debate is likely to continue. But one thing is certain: the shoes left behind by Virat Kohli at No. 3 won’t be easy to fill—and the decision could shape India’s batting fortunes for years to come.

topbabyworlds.com